{
 "name": "SkinSafeCheck comedogenic ratings, with who rated each one",
 "version": "1.0.0",
 "released": "2026-10-08",
 "licence": "CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) for the list ratings and the provenance notes. Paper grades are facts reported with attribution; cite the papers.",
 "cite_as": "SkinSafeCheck. Comedogenic ratings, with who rated each one. Version 1.0.0, 2026-10-08. https://skinsafecheck.com/data/",
 "described_at": "https://skinsafecheck.com/data/",
 "not_medical_advice": "Every grade is for a raw ingredient tested on a rabbit ear. None predicts how a product will behave on a person.",
 "papers": {
  "fulton1989": "Fulton JE Jr. Comedogenicity and irritancy of commonly used ingredients in skin care products. J Soc Cosmet Chem 1989;40(6):321-333.",
  "morris1983": "Morris WE, Kwan SC. Use of the rabbit ear model in evaluating the comedogenic potential of cosmetic ingredients. J Soc Cosmet Chem 1983;34(5):215-225.",
  "fulton1976": "Fulton JE Jr, Bradley S, Aqundez A, Black T. Non-comedogenic cosmetics. Cutis 1976;17(2):344-351. Abstract only.",
  "nguyen2007": "Nguyen SH, Dang TP, Maibach HI. Comedogenicity in rabbit: some cosmetic ingredients/vehicles. Cutan Ocul Toxicol 2007;26(4):287-292. Abstract only."
 },
 "columns": {
  "ingredient": "The ingredient as our list names it.",
  "slug": "A stable identifier, the last part of the page URL.",
  "page_url": "The ingredient page on skinsafecheck.com, with the papers in full.",
  "list_rating": "Our list’s comedogenic rating, 0 to 5, as published. A range means published ratings disagree.",
  "list_min": "The low end of the list rating.",
  "list_max": "The high end of the list rating.",
  "list_is_range": "true when the list gives a range.",
  "status": "traced: at least one paper we read grades it. untraced: we checked and could not tie the number to a paper we have read. not_yet_checked: not yet compared with the papers.",
  "fulton1989_grade": "The comedogenicity grade Fulton 1989 printed, as printed. \"2(1)\" is crude oil 2, refined 1. Several values are separated by semicolons.",
  "fulton1989_tested_as": "The name Fulton 1989 printed for the material tested, where it differs, with any note on it being the same substance.",
  "fulton1989_conditions": "How Fulton 1989 tested it.",
  "morris1983_grade": "The comedogenic grade Morris and Kwan 1983 printed.",
  "morris1983_tested_as": "The name and dilution Morris and Kwan 1983 printed.",
  "morris1983_conditions": "How Morris and Kwan 1983 tested it.",
  "other_findings": "What a paper read at abstract level says, without a grade.",
  "untraced_note": "For untraced rows, what we checked and did not find.",
  "list_above_research": "true when our list’s highest figure is above every grade the papers give.",
  "list_vs_research": "One sentence comparing the list with the papers."
 },
 "rows": [
  {
   "ingredient": "1-Acetoxyhexadecane",
   "slug": "1-acetoxyhexadecane",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/1-acetoxyhexadecane/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetyl acetate (the same substance)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's lowest figure, 3, is lower than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "1-Hexadecanol Acetate",
   "slug": "1-hexadecanol-acetate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/1-hexadecanol-acetate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetyl acetate (the same substance)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's lowest figure, 3, is lower than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "A & D Additive",
   "slug": "a-and-d-additive",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/a-and-d-additive/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "A & D additive",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Acai Berry Oil",
   "slug": "acai-berry-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/acai-berry-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Acetol",
   "slug": "acetol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/acetol/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Acetulan",
   "slug": "acetulan",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/acetulan/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Acetylated lanolin alcohol (Acetulan is its trade name)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "4-5",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Acetylated Lanolin Alcohol (trade name Acetulan)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Acetylated Lanolin",
   "slug": "acetylated-lanolin",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/acetylated-lanolin/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Acetylated lanolin",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Acetylated Lanolin Alcohol",
   "slug": "acetylated-lanolin-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/acetylated-lanolin-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Acetylated lanolin alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Active Soil Complex",
   "slug": "active-soil-complex",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/active-soil-complex/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Agar",
   "slug": "agar",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/agar/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ahnfeltia Concinna",
   "slug": "ahnfeltia-concinna",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ahnfeltia-concinna/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Alaria Esculenta",
   "slug": "alaria-esculenta",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/alaria-esculenta/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Algae / Algae Extract",
   "slug": "algae-algae-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/algae-algae-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Algin / Alginate",
   "slug": "algin-alginate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/algin-alginate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Aloe Butter",
   "slug": "aloe-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/aloe-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Almond Oil (Sweet)",
   "slug": "almond-oil-sweet",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/almond-oil-sweet/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2(1)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Almond oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Sweet Almond Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Amaranth Oil",
   "slug": "amaranth-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/amaranth-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Andiroba Seed Oil",
   "slug": "andiroba-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/andiroba-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Anhydrous Lanolin",
   "slug": "anhydrous-lanolin",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/anhydrous-lanolin/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Anhydrous lanolin",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Apricot Kernel Oil (Prunus Armeniaca)",
   "slug": "apricot-kernel-oil-prunus-armeniaca",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/apricot-kernel-oil-prunus-armeniaca/",
   "list_rating": "2–5",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2(1)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Apricot kernel oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Arachidic Acid",
   "slug": "arachidic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/arachidic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Eicosanoic acid (arachidic acid is the same substance)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Argan Oil (Argania Spinosa)",
   "slug": "argan-oil-argania-spinosa",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/argan-oil-argania-spinosa/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests argan oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ascophyllum Nodosum",
   "slug": "ascophyllum-nodosum",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ascophyllum-nodosum/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ascorbyl Palmitate",
   "slug": "ascorbyl-palmitate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ascorbyl-palmitate/",
   "list_rating": "2–5",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Ascorbyl palmitate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Astrocaryum Murumuru Seed Butter",
   "slug": "astrocaryum-murumuru-seed-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/astrocaryum-murumuru-seed-butter/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Avocado Butter",
   "slug": "avocado-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/avocado-butter/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Avocado Oil (Persea Gratissima)",
   "slug": "avocado-oil-persea-gratissima",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/avocado-oil-persea-gratissima/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3(2)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Avocado oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "0",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Avocado Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Babassu Butter",
   "slug": "babassu-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/babassu-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Babassu Oil",
   "slug": "babassu-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/babassu-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Babassu oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Baobab Oil",
   "slug": "baobab-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/baobab-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Beef Tallow",
   "slug": "beef-tallow",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/beef-tallow/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Beeswax (Cera Alba)",
   "slug": "beeswax-cera-alba",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/beeswax-cera-alba/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Beeswax",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Behenic Acid",
   "slug": "behenic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/behenic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Behenic acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Benzaldehyde",
   "slug": "benzaldehyde",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/benzaldehyde/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Benzoic Acid",
   "slug": "benzoic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/benzoic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests benzoic acid.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Bismuth / Bismuth Oxychloride",
   "slug": "bismuth-bismuth-oxychloride",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/bismuth-bismuth-oxychloride/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests bismuth oxychloride.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Black Cumin Seed Oil",
   "slug": "black-cumin-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/black-cumin-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests black cumin seed oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Black Kelp",
   "slug": "black-kelp",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/black-kelp/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Bladderwrack",
   "slug": "bladderwrack",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/bladderwrack/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Blue / Blue Green Algae",
   "slug": "blue-blue-green-algae",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/blue-blue-green-algae/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Borage Oil",
   "slug": "borage-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/borage-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Brazil Nut Oil",
   "slug": "brazil-nut-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/brazil-nut-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Broccoli Butter",
   "slug": "broccoli-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/broccoli-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Brown Algae",
   "slug": "brown-algae",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/brown-algae/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Buriti Oil",
   "slug": "buriti-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/buriti-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Butyl Stearate",
   "slug": "butyl-stearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/butyl-stearate/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Butyl stearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea Butter)",
   "slug": "butyrospermum-parkii-shea-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/butyrospermum-parkii-shea-butter/",
   "list_rating": "0–5",
   "list_min": 0,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests shea butter.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cacao Seed Butter",
   "slug": "cacao-seed-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cacao-seed-butter/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cocoa butter (the same fat)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cajeput Oil",
   "slug": "cajeput-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cajeput-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Calendula Extract",
   "slug": "calendula-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/calendula-extract/",
   "list_rating": "1",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 1,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Camellia Oil",
   "slug": "camellia-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/camellia-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Camphor / Camphor Oil",
   "slug": "camphor-camphor-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/camphor-camphor-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Canola Oil",
   "slug": "canola-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/canola-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Capric Acid",
   "slug": "capric-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/capric-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Capric acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Carnauba Wax",
   "slug": "carnauba-wax",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/carnauba-wax/",
   "list_rating": "1",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 1,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Carnuba wax",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Carrageenan (Chondrus Crispus) / Carrageenan Moss",
   "slug": "carrageenan-chondrus-crispus-carrageenan-moss",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/carrageenan-chondrus-crispus-carrageenan-moss/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Carrot Butter",
   "slug": "carrot-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/carrot-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Carrot Seed Oil",
   "slug": "carrot-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/carrot-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests carrot seed oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Castor Oil (Ricinus Communis)",
   "slug": "castor-oil-ricinus-communis",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/castor-oil-ricinus-communis/",
   "list_rating": "1–2",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Castor oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "0-1",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Castor Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Caulerpa Lentillifera Extract",
   "slug": "caulerpa-lentillifera-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/caulerpa-lentillifera-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ceteareth-20",
   "slug": "ceteareth-20",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ceteareth-20/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2; 4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Ceteareth-20; Cetearyl alcohol + ceteareth 20",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cetearyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "cetearyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cetearyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetearyl alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cetearyl Alcohol + Ceteareth 20",
   "slug": "cetearyl-alcohol-plus-ceteareth-20",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cetearyl-alcohol-plus-ceteareth-20/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetearyl alcohol + ceteareth 20",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cetyl Acetate",
   "slug": "cetyl-acetate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cetyl-acetate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetyl acetate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cetyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "cetyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cetyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetyl alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Chaetomorpha Linum",
   "slug": "chaetomorpha-linum",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/chaetomorpha-linum/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Chaulmoogra Oil",
   "slug": "chaulmoogra-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/chaulmoogra-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Chaulmoogra oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cherry Seed Oil",
   "slug": "cherry-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cherry-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Chlorella / Chlorella Vulgaris Extract",
   "slug": "chlorella-chlorella-vulgaris-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/chlorella-chlorella-vulgaris-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cladosiphon Okamuranus Extract",
   "slug": "cladosiphon-okamuranus-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cladosiphon-okamuranus-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Coal Tar",
   "slug": "coal-tar",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/coal-tar/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cocoa Butter (Theobroma Cacao)",
   "slug": "cocoa-butter-theobroma-cacao",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cocoa-butter-theobroma-cacao/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cocoa butter",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "Nguyen and colleagues 2007 lists cocoa butter among the materials deemed positive",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Coconut Alkanes",
   "slug": "coconut-alkanes",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/coconut-alkanes/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Coconut Butter",
   "slug": "coconut-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/coconut-butter/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Coconut butter",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Coconut Oil (Cocos Nucifera)",
   "slug": "coconut-oil-cocos-nucifera",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/coconut-oil-cocos-nucifera/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests coconut oil. Fulton 1989 rates coconut butter 4, which our list carries as a separate entry.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Coffee Butter",
   "slug": "coffee-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/coffee-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Colloidal Sulfur",
   "slug": "colloidal-sulfur",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/colloidal-sulfur/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper tests colloidal sulfur by that name. Fulton 1989 graded precipitated sulfur 0 and water-soluble sulfur 3.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Corallina Officinalis / Corallina Officinalis Extract",
   "slug": "corallina-officinalis-corallina-officinalis-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/corallina-officinalis-corallina-officinalis-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Corn Oil (Zea Mays)",
   "slug": "corn-oil-zea-mays",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/corn-oil-zea-mays/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Corn oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "0-1",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Corn Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cotton Seed Oil",
   "slug": "cotton-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cotton-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cotton seed oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cranberry Butter",
   "slug": "cranberry-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cranberry-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Cranberry Seed Oil",
   "slug": "cranberry-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/cranberry-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "D&C Red Pigments (#3, 17, 19, 21, 27, 30, 36, 40)",
   "slug": "d-and-c-red-pigments-3-17-19-21-27-30-36-40",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/d-and-c-red-pigments-3-17-19-21-27-30-36-40/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Date Seed Oil",
   "slug": "date-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/date-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Decyl Oleate",
   "slug": "decyl-oleate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/decyl-oleate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Decyl oleate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Decyl Oleate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Di (2-ethylhexyl) Succinate",
   "slug": "di-2-ethylhexyl-succinate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/di-2-ethylhexyl-succinate/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Di (2 ethylhexyl) succinate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Dictyopteris Membranacea",
   "slug": "dictyopteris-membranacea",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/dictyopteris-membranacea/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Dioctyl Malate",
   "slug": "dioctyl-malate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/dioctyl-malate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Dioctyl malate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Dioctyl Succinate",
   "slug": "dioctyl-succinate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/dioctyl-succinate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Dioctyl succinate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Disodium Laureth Sulfosuccinate",
   "slug": "disodium-laureth-sulfosuccinate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/disodium-laureth-sulfosuccinate/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Disodium Monooleamido PEG-2 / PEG-2 Sulfosuccinate",
   "slug": "disodium-monooleamido-peg-2-peg-2-sulfosuccinate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/disodium-monooleamido-peg-2-peg-2-sulfosuccinate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Dodecanoic Acid (Lauric Acid)",
   "slug": "dodecanoic-acid-lauric-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/dodecanoic-acid-lauric-acid/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Lauric acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Dulse (Palmaria Palmata)",
   "slug": "dulse-palmaria-palmata",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/dulse-palmaria-palmata/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Dunaliella Salina Extract",
   "slug": "dunaliella-salina-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/dunaliella-salina-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ecklonia (all species) / Ecklonia Cava Extract",
   "slug": "ecklonia-all-species-ecklonia-cava-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ecklonia-all-species-ecklonia-cava-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Eicosanoic Acid",
   "slug": "eicosanoic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/eicosanoic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Eicosanoic acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Emu Oil",
   "slug": "emu-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/emu-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests emu oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Emulsifying Wax NF",
   "slug": "emulsifying-wax-nf",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/emulsifying-wax-nf/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Emulsifying wax NF",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Enteromorpha Compressa",
   "slug": "enteromorpha-compressa",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/enteromorpha-compressa/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ethoxylated Lanolin",
   "slug": "ethoxylated-lanolin",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ethoxylated-lanolin/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ethylhexyl Palmitate",
   "slug": "ethylhexyl-palmitate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ethylhexyl-palmitate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Ethylhexyl palmitate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "2-3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Octyl Palmitate (the older name)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ethylhexyl Pelargonate",
   "slug": "ethylhexyl-pelargonate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ethylhexyl-pelargonate/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Ethylhexyl pelargonate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ethylhexyl Stearate",
   "slug": "ethylhexyl-stearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ethylhexyl-stearate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests ethylhexyl stearate.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Evening Primrose Oil",
   "slug": "evening-primrose-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/evening-primrose-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Evening primrose oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's lowest figure, 2, is lower than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Flaxseed Oil (Linseed Oil)",
   "slug": "flaxseed-oil-linseed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/flaxseed-oil-linseed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Fucoxanthin",
   "slug": "fucoxanthin",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/fucoxanthin/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests fucoxanthin.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Fucus Vesiculosus",
   "slug": "fucus-vesiculosus",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/fucus-vesiculosus/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Gelidiella Acerosa Extract",
   "slug": "gelidiella-acerosa-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/gelidiella-acerosa-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Gelidium Cartilagineum",
   "slug": "gelidium-cartilagineum",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/gelidium-cartilagineum/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Gigartina Stellata Extract",
   "slug": "gigartina-stellata-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/gigartina-stellata-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Glyceryl Oleate",
   "slug": "glyceryl-oleate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/glyceryl-oleate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests glyceryl oleate.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Glyceryl Stearate SE",
   "slug": "glyceryl-stearate-se",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/glyceryl-stearate-se/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Glyceryl stearate SE",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Glyceryl-3-Diisostearate",
   "slug": "glyceryl-3-diisostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/glyceryl-3-diisostearate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Glyceryl-3-diisostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Glycine Soja (Soybean) Oil",
   "slug": "glycine-soja-soybean-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/glycine-soja-soybean-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Soybean oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Grapeseed Butter",
   "slug": "grapeseed-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/grapeseed-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Grapeseed Oil (Vitis Vinifera)",
   "slug": "grapeseed-oil-vitis-vinifera",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/grapeseed-oil-vitis-vinifera/",
   "list_rating": "1–4",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "2-3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Grape Seed Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers. Our list's lowest figure, 1, is lower than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Groundnut Oil",
   "slug": "groundnut-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/groundnut-oil/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Peanut oil (groundnut oil is the same oil)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Guava Seed Oil",
   "slug": "guava-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/guava-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Haematococcus Pluvialis Extract",
   "slug": "haematococcus-pluvialis-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/haematococcus-pluvialis-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Haslea Ostrearia / Haslea Ostrearia Extract",
   "slug": "haslea-ostrearia-haslea-ostrearia-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/haslea-ostrearia-haslea-ostrearia-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hazelnut Seed Oil",
   "slug": "hazelnut-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hazelnut-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests hazelnut oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hemp Seed Oil",
   "slug": "hemp-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hemp-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "0",
   "list_min": 0,
   "list_max": 0,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests hemp seed oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hexadecanol Acetate",
   "slug": "hexadecanol-acetate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hexadecanol-acetate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetyl acetate (the same substance)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's lowest figure, 3, is lower than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hexadecyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "hexadecyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hexadecyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Cetyl alcohol (the same substance)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hexylene Glycol",
   "slug": "hexylene-glycol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hexylene-glycol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Hexylene glycol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Himanthalia Elongata / Himanthalia Elongata Extract",
   "slug": "himanthalia-elongata-himanthalia-elongata-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/himanthalia-elongata-himanthalia-elongata-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hizikia Fusiforme Extract",
   "slug": "hizikia-fusiforme-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hizikia-fusiforme-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hydrogenated Castor Oil",
   "slug": "hydrogenated-castor-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hydrogenated-castor-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Hydrogenated castor oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil",
   "slug": "hydrogenated-vegetable-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hydrogenated-vegetable-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Hydrogenated vegetable oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hydrolyzed Rhodophyceae Extract",
   "slug": "hydrolyzed-rhodophyceae-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hydrolyzed-rhodophyceae-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Hypnea Musciformis / Hypnea Musciformis Extract",
   "slug": "hypnea-musciformis-hypnea-musciformis-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/hypnea-musciformis-hypnea-musciformis-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Illipe Butter",
   "slug": "illipe-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/illipe-butter/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Irish Moss",
   "slug": "irish-moss",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/irish-moss/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isocetyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "isocetyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isocetyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isocetyl alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isocetyl Stearate",
   "slug": "isocetyl-stearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isocetyl-stearate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "0-1",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isocetyl Stearate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isodecyl Oleate",
   "slug": "isodecyl-oleate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isodecyl-oleate/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2-3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isodecyl oleate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "1",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isodecyl Oleate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isopropyl Isostearate",
   "slug": "isopropyl-isostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isopropyl-isostearate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "5",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isopropyl isostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "4",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isopropyl Isostearate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isopropyl Lanolate",
   "slug": "isopropyl-lanolate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isopropyl-lanolate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isopropyl Lanolate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isopropyl Linoleate / Isopropyl Linolate",
   "slug": "isopropyl-linoleate-isopropyl-linolate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isopropyl-linoleate-isopropyl-linolate/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isopropyl linolate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "4-5",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isopropyl Linoleate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isopropyl Myristate",
   "slug": "isopropyl-myristate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isopropyl-myristate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "5",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isopropyl myristate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "3-4",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isopropyl Myristate (50% in propylene glycol)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isopropyl Neopentanoate",
   "slug": "isopropyl-neopentanoate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isopropyl-neopentanoate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isopropyl Palmitate",
   "slug": "isopropyl-palmitate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isopropyl-palmitate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isopropyl palmitate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Isopropyl Palmitate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isostearic Acid",
   "slug": "isostearic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isostearic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests isostearic acid.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isostearyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "isostearyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isostearyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isostearyl Isostearate",
   "slug": "isostearyl-isostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isostearyl-isostearate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isostearyl isostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Isostearyl Neopentanoate",
   "slug": "isostearyl-neopentanoate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/isostearyl-neopentanoate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Isostearyl neopentanoate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Jania Rubens Extract",
   "slug": "jania-rubens-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/jania-rubens-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Jojoba Butter",
   "slug": "jojoba-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/jojoba-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Jojoba Oil / Butter",
   "slug": "jojoba-oil-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/jojoba-oil-butter/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Jojoba oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Jojoba Wax",
   "slug": "jojoba-wax",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/jojoba-wax/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Kapok Oil",
   "slug": "kapok-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/kapok-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–5",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Kappaphycus Alvarezii Extract",
   "slug": "kappaphycus-alvarezii-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/kappaphycus-alvarezii-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Karanja Oil",
   "slug": "karanja-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/karanja-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Kelp (Macrocystis Pyrifera)",
   "slug": "kelp-macrocystis-pyrifera",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/kelp-macrocystis-pyrifera/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Kukui Nut Butter",
   "slug": "kukui-nut-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/kukui-nut-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests kukui nut butter.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Kukui Nut Oil",
   "slug": "kukui-nut-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/kukui-nut-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Laminaria (all species) / Laminaria Digitata / Laminaria Saccharina",
   "slug": "laminaria-all-species-laminaria-digitata-laminaria-saccharina",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/laminaria-all-species-laminaria-digitata-laminaria-saccharina/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Laneth-10",
   "slug": "laneth-10",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/laneth-10/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Laneth-10",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lanolic Acid",
   "slug": "lanolic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lanolic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "4",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Lanolin Acid (50% in mineral oil)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lanolin / Lanolin Oil / Lanolin Acid",
   "slug": "lanolin-lanolin-oil-lanolin-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lanolin-lanolin-oil-lanolin-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Lanolin oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "0; 4",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Lanolin (Super Corona); Lanolin Acid (50% in mineral oil)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lanolin Alcohol",
   "slug": "lanolin-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lanolin-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Lanolin alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "1-2",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Lanolin Alcohol (30% in mineral oil)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lanolin Wax",
   "slug": "lanolin-wax",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lanolin-wax/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Lanolin wax",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Laureth-4",
   "slug": "laureth-4",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/laureth-4/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "5",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Laureth-4",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Laureth-23",
   "slug": "laureth-23",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/laureth-23/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Laureth-23",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lauric Acid",
   "slug": "lauric-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lauric-acid/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Lauric acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lauryl Alcohol",
   "slug": "lauryl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lauryl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Linseed Oil",
   "slug": "linseed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/linseed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests linseed oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Lithothamnium Calcareum",
   "slug": "lithothamnium-calcareum",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/lithothamnium-calcareum/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Macadamia Nut Butter",
   "slug": "macadamia-nut-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/macadamia-nut-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Macadamia Nut Oil / Macadamia Oil",
   "slug": "macadamia-nut-oil-macadamia-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/macadamia-nut-oil-macadamia-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–5",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests macadamia oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Macrocystis Pyrifera Extract",
   "slug": "macrocystis-pyrifera-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/macrocystis-pyrifera-extract/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Magnesium Myristate",
   "slug": "magnesium-myristate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/magnesium-myristate/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Mahua Seed Oil",
   "slug": "mahua-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/mahua-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Mango Seed Butter / Oil",
   "slug": "mango-seed-butter-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/mango-seed-butter-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests mango seed butter.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Marine Algae",
   "slug": "marine-algae",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/marine-algae/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Marula Oil",
   "slug": "marula-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/marula-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests marula oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Mastocarpus Stellatus",
   "slug": "mastocarpus-stellatus",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/mastocarpus-stellatus/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Mineral Oil",
   "slug": "mineral-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/mineral-oil/",
   "list_rating": "1–3",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Mineral oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Mink Oil",
   "slug": "mink-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/mink-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3(2)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Mink oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Moringa Oil",
   "slug": "moringa-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/moringa-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Mowrah Butter",
   "slug": "mowrah-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/mowrah-butter/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Myreth-3 Myristate",
   "slug": "myreth-3-myristate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/myreth-3-myristate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests myreth-3 myristate.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Myristic Acid",
   "slug": "myristic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/myristic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Myristic acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Myristyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "myristyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/myristyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Myristyl alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Myristyl Lactate",
   "slug": "myristyl-lactate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/myristyl-lactate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Myristyl lactate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Myristyl Myristate",
   "slug": "myristyl-myristate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/myristyl-myristate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "5",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Myristyl myristate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "0-1",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Myristyl Myristate (50% in mineral oil)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Myristyl Propionate",
   "slug": "myristyl-propionate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/myristyl-propionate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Neem Butter",
   "slug": "neem-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/neem-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests neem butter.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Neem Oil",
   "slug": "neem-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/neem-oil/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests neem oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Nori",
   "slug": "nori",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/nori/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Norwegian Kelp",
   "slug": "norwegian-kelp",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/norwegian-kelp/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Octyl Palmitate",
   "slug": "octyl-palmitate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/octyl-palmitate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Ethylhexyl palmitate (octyl palmitate is the older name)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "2-3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Octyl Palmitate",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Octyl Stearate",
   "slug": "octyl-stearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/octyl-stearate/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Octyldodecanol",
   "slug": "octyldodecanol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/octyldodecanol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests octyldodecanol. Fulton 1989 rates two octyldodecyl esters, which are different ingredients.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Olea Europaea (Olive) Oil",
   "slug": "olea-europaea-olive-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/olea-europaea-olive-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2(1)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Olive oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "0",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Olive Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Oleic Acid",
   "slug": "oleic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/oleic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither rating table we read grades oleic acid. Motoyoshi 1983 found that oleic acid produced fairly large comedones on the rabbit ear, without giving a 0 to 5 grade.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Oleth-3 / Oleth-3 Phosphate",
   "slug": "oleth-3-oleth-3-phosphate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/oleth-3-oleth-3-phosphate/",
   "list_rating": "2–5",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "5; 2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Oleth-3; Oleth-3 phosphate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Oleth-5",
   "slug": "oleth-5",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/oleth-5/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Oleth-5",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Oleth-10",
   "slug": "oleth-10",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/oleth-10/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Oleth-10",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Oleyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "oleyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/oleyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Oleyl alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Olive Butter",
   "slug": "olive-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/olive-butter/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Padina Pavonica",
   "slug": "padina-pavonica",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/padina-pavonica/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Palm Kernel Oil",
   "slug": "palm-kernel-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/palm-kernel-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests palm kernel oil itself.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Palm Oil",
   "slug": "palm-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/palm-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Palmaria Palmata",
   "slug": "palmaria-palmata",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/palmaria-palmata/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Palmitic Acid",
   "slug": "palmitic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/palmitic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Palmitic acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Papaya Seed Oil",
   "slug": "papaya-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/papaya-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Passionfruit (Maracuja) Seed Oil",
   "slug": "passionfruit-maracuja-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/passionfruit-maracuja-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Peach Kernel Oil",
   "slug": "peach-kernel-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peach-kernel-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "2",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Peach Kernel Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Peanut Oil",
   "slug": "peanut-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peanut-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Peanut oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Pecan Oil",
   "slug": "pecan-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pecan-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PEG 100 / PEG 150 Distearate",
   "slug": "peg-100-peg-150-distearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peg-100-peg-150-distearate/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2; 2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PEG 100 distearate; PEG 150 distearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PEG 16 Lanolin (Solulan 16)",
   "slug": "peg-16-lanolin-solulan-16",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peg-16-lanolin-solulan-16/",
   "list_rating": "4–5",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PEG 16 lanolin (Solulan 16)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PEG 200 Dilaurate",
   "slug": "peg-200-dilaurate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peg-200-dilaurate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PEG 200 dilaurate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PEG 8 Castor Oil",
   "slug": "peg-8-castor-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peg-8-castor-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PEG 8 castor oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 2, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PEG 8 Stearate",
   "slug": "peg-8-stearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peg-8-stearate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PEG 8 stearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil",
   "slug": "peg-40-hydrogenated-castor-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/peg-40-hydrogenated-castor-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests PEG-40 hydrogenated castor oil. Fulton 1989 rates PEG 40 castor oil, which is not hydrogenated.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Pelvetia Canaliculata Extract",
   "slug": "pelvetia-canaliculata-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pelvetia-canaliculata-extract/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Pentaerythrityl Tetraisostearate",
   "slug": "pentaerythrityl-tetraisostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pentaerythrityl-tetraisostearate/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Pentaerythrital tetra isostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Perilla Oil",
   "slug": "perilla-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/perilla-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests perilla oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PG Caprylate/Caprate",
   "slug": "pg-caprylate-caprate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pg-caprylate-caprate/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PG caprylate/caprate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PG Dipelargonate",
   "slug": "pg-dipelargonate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pg-dipelargonate/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PG dipelargonate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PG Monostearate",
   "slug": "pg-monostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pg-monostearate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PG monostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Phytantriol",
   "slug": "phytantriol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/phytantriol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Phytantriol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Phytessence Wakame",
   "slug": "phytessence-wakame",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/phytessence-wakame/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Plankton / Plankton Extract",
   "slug": "plankton-plankton-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/plankton-plankton-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Plum Seed Oil",
   "slug": "plum-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/plum-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Polyglyceryl-3-Diisostearate",
   "slug": "polyglyceryl-3-diisostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/polyglyceryl-3-diisostearate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Polyglyceryl-3-diisostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Porphyra / Porphyra Umbilicalis",
   "slug": "porphyra-porphyra-umbilicalis",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/porphyra-porphyra-umbilicalis/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Porphyridium Cruentum",
   "slug": "porphyridium-cruentum",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/porphyridium-cruentum/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Potassium Chloride",
   "slug": "potassium-chloride",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/potassium-chloride/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PPG 10 Cetyl Ether",
   "slug": "ppg-10-cetyl-ether",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ppg-10-cetyl-ether/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PPG 10 cetyl ether",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PPG 12 PEG 65 Lanolin Oil",
   "slug": "ppg-12-peg-65-lanolin-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ppg-12-peg-65-lanolin-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PPG 12 PEG 65 lanolin oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PPG 2 Myristyl Propionate",
   "slug": "ppg-2-myristyl-propionate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ppg-2-myristyl-propionate/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PPG 2 myristyl propionate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "PPG 5 Ceteth 10 Phosphate",
   "slug": "ppg-5-ceteth-10-phosphate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ppg-5-ceteth-10-phosphate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PPG 5 Ceteth 10 phosphate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Prickly Pear Seed Oil",
   "slug": "prickly-pear-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/prickly-pear-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "1–2",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests prickly pear seed oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Propylene Glycol Monostearate",
   "slug": "propylene-glycol-monostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/propylene-glycol-monostearate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PG monostearate (the same substance)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 4, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Pumpkin Seed Oil",
   "slug": "pumpkin-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/pumpkin-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Rapeseed Oil",
   "slug": "rapeseed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/rapeseed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Red Algae",
   "slug": "red-algae",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/red-algae/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Rice Bran Oil",
   "slug": "rice-bran-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/rice-bran-oil/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests rice bran oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Rockweed",
   "slug": "rockweed",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/rockweed/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Rosehip Seed Oil / Butter",
   "slug": "rosehip-seed-oil-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/rosehip-seed-oil-butter/",
   "list_rating": "1–5",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests rosehip oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Safflower Oil (Cooking variety)",
   "slug": "safflower-oil-cooking-variety",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/safflower-oil-cooking-variety/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Fulton 1989 graded safflower oil 0 and Morris and Kwan 1983 graded it 1 to 2, but neither says which type they tested, so neither figure can be tied to this entry.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sal Seed Butter",
   "slug": "sal-seed-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sal-seed-butter/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sandalwood Seed Oil",
   "slug": "sandalwood-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sandalwood-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sandalwood seed oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sargassum / Sargassum Extract",
   "slug": "sargassum-sargassum-extract",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sargassum-sargassum-extract/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Seaweed / Sea Grass / Sea Whip",
   "slug": "seaweed-sea-grass-sea-whip",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/seaweed-sea-grass-sea-whip/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract. We found no study showing that iodine in a seaweed extract put on the skin causes acne; acne from iodine is reported from iodides taken by mouth.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sesame Oil / Sesame Seed Oil",
   "slug": "sesame-oil-sesame-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sesame-oil-sesame-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3(1)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sesame oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "1",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Sesame Oil (Lipoval SES)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Shark Liver Oil",
   "slug": "shark-liver-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/shark-liver-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Shark liver oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sodium Alginate",
   "slug": "sodium-alginate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sodium-alginate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sodium Laureth Sulfate (SLES)",
   "slug": "sodium-laureth-sulfate-sles",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sodium-laureth-sulfate-sles/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests sodium laureth sulfate.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS)",
   "slug": "sodium-lauryl-sulfate-sls",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sodium-lauryl-sulfate-sls/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "0; 0",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (10% aqueous); Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (5% aqueous)",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "Fulton 1976 names sodium lauryl sulfate among the emulsifiers it found comedogenic, without a grade in the abstract; Nguyen and colleagues 2007 tested it and did not list it among the materials deemed positive",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Solulan 16",
   "slug": "solulan-16",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/solulan-16/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "PEG 16 lanolin (Solulan 16)",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sorbitan Isostearate",
   "slug": "sorbitan-isostearate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sorbitan-isostearate/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sorbitan isostearate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 3, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sorbitan Laurate",
   "slug": "sorbitan-laurate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sorbitan-laurate/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1-2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sorbitan laurate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sorbitan Oleate",
   "slug": "sorbitan-oleate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sorbitan-oleate/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sorbitan oleate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Spirulina",
   "slug": "spirulina",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/spirulina/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Squalene (Shark derived)",
   "slug": "squalene-shark-derived",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/squalene-shark-derived/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Steareth-10",
   "slug": "steareth-10",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/steareth-10/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Steareth-10",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Steareth-2 / Steareth-20",
   "slug": "steareth-2-steareth-20",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/steareth-2-steareth-20/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2; 2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Steareth-2; Steareth-20",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Stearic Acid",
   "slug": "stearic-acid",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/stearic-acid/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2-3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Stearic acid",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Stearic Acid TEA",
   "slug": "stearic-acid-tea",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/stearic-acid-tea/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Stearic acid: TEA",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Stearyl Alcohol",
   "slug": "stearyl-alcohol",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/stearyl-alcohol/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Stearyl alcohol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Stearyl Heptanoate",
   "slug": "stearyl-heptanoate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/stearyl-heptanoate/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Stearyl heptanoate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sulfated Castor Oil",
   "slug": "sulfated-castor-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sulfated-castor-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests sulfated castor oil. Fulton 1989 grades castor oil 1, a different ingredient.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sulfated Jojoba Oil",
   "slug": "sulfated-jojoba-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sulfated-jojoba-oil/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sulfated jojoba oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sunflower Oil (GMO) / Butter",
   "slug": "sunflower-oil-gmo-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sunflower-oil-gmo-butter/",
   "list_rating": "1–5",
   "list_min": 1,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Sunflower oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Sweet Almond Oil / Butter",
   "slug": "sweet-almond-oil-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/sweet-almond-oil-butter/",
   "list_rating": "3–5",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2(1)",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Almond oil",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "3",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "Sweet Almond Oil",
   "morris1983_conditions": "rabbit ear, undiluted unless stated, 14 applications",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": true,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's top figure, 5, is higher than anything in these papers."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Tallow",
   "slug": "tallow",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/tallow/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests tallow.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Tamanu Oil / Butter",
   "slug": "tamanu-oil-butter",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/tamanu-oil-butter/",
   "list_rating": "2–5",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests tamanu oil.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Tocopherol (Vitamin E)",
   "slug": "tocopherol-vitamin-e",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/tocopherol-vitamin-e/",
   "list_rating": "0–3",
   "list_min": 0,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "0-3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Tocopherol",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Tomato Seed Oil",
   "slug": "tomato-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/tomato-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Tribehenin",
   "slug": "tribehenin",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/tribehenin/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests tribehenin by that name.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Triethanolamine",
   "slug": "triethanolamine",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/triethanolamine/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "2",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Triethanolamine",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Ulva Lactuca",
   "slug": "ulva-lactuca",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/ulva-lactuca/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Undaria / Undaria Pinnatifida",
   "slug": "undaria-undaria-pinnatifida",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/undaria-undaria-pinnatifida/",
   "list_rating": "2–4",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Vitamin A Palmitate",
   "slug": "vitamin-a-palmitate",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/vitamin-a-palmitate/",
   "list_rating": "2–3",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "1-3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Vitamin A palmitate",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks; result varied with the supplier",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Wakame",
   "slug": "wakame",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/wakame/",
   "list_rating": "3–4",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": true,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests any algae extract.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Walnut Seed Oil",
   "slug": "walnut-seed-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/walnut-seed-oil/",
   "list_rating": "2",
   "list_min": 2,
   "list_max": 2,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "not_yet_checked",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Water-Soluble Sulfur",
   "slug": "water-soluble-sulfur",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/water-soluble-sulfur/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Water-soluble sulfur",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Wheat Germ Glyceride",
   "slug": "wheat-germ-glyceride",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/wheat-germ-glyceride/",
   "list_rating": "3",
   "list_min": 3,
   "list_max": 3,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "3",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Wheat germ glyceride",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Wheat Germ Oil",
   "slug": "wheat-germ-oil",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/wheat-germ-oil/",
   "list_rating": "5",
   "list_min": 5,
   "list_max": 5,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests wheat germ oil. Fulton 1989 grades wheat germ glyceride 3, which our list carries as a separate entry.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Xylene",
   "slug": "xylene",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/xylene/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "traced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "4",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "Xylene",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "rabbit ear, 10% in propylene glycol unless stated, two weeks",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": "Our list's figure is within what these papers report."
  },
  {
   "ingredient": "Zea Mays (Corn Starch)",
   "slug": "zea-mays-corn-starch",
   "page_url": "https://skinsafecheck.com/ingredient/zea-mays-corn-starch/",
   "list_rating": "4",
   "list_min": 4,
   "list_max": 4,
   "list_is_range": false,
   "status": "untraced",
   "fulton1989_grade": "",
   "fulton1989_tested_as": "",
   "fulton1989_conditions": "",
   "morris1983_grade": "",
   "morris1983_tested_as": "",
   "morris1983_conditions": "",
   "other_findings": "",
   "untraced_note": "Neither paper we could read tests corn starch. Fulton 1989 rates corn oil, a different ingredient.",
   "list_above_research": false,
   "list_vs_research": ""
  }
 ]
}